Chapter 4 — Thursday

Why Thursday? A childhood accident, repeated anaesthesia, fear of not waking, and the nurse whose reassurance stayed with me.

Explore the Layers
Chapters

Move to another chapter in the book.

  1. Chapter 1 — The Record
  2. Chapter 2 — Forty-Five Geologists
  3. Chapter 3 — Behind the Chronicle
  4. Chapter 4 — Thursday
  5. Chapter 5 — Robert
  6. Chapter 6 — Janette
  7. Chapter 7 — The Melbourne Process
  8. Chapter 8 — Patrick Smith
  9. Chapter 9 — Canada
  10. Chapter 10 — When the Patient Meets the Record
  11. Chapter 11 — The Life That Followed
  12. Chapter 12 — Work, Roads and Country
  13. Chapter 13 — Building a Life
  14. Chapter 14 — What Memory Did With It
  15. Chapter 15 — When the Past Began Returning
  16. Chapter 16 — Making Connections
  17. Chapter 17 — Following the Records
  18. Chapter 18 — The Cost of Being Disbelieved
  19. Chapter 19 — Building the Evidence
  20. Chapter 20 — Reclaiming the Record
  21. Chapter 21 — Germaine
  22. Chapter 22 — Herbie
  23. Chapter 23 — Through the Glass
  24. Chapter 24 — What Happened to Herbie's Story
  25. Chapter 25 — The Adults Around Yea
  26. Chapter 26 — 2007
  27. Chapter 27 — A Diagnosis That Travelled
  28. Chapter 28 — Finding Julian Lim
  29. Chapter 29 — When Meditation Opened the Wrong Door
  30. Chapter 30 — The Tests
  31. Chapter 31 — When Hell Becomes a Threat
  32. Chapter 32 — The Child of Satan
  33. Chapter 33 — What Adults Called an Exorcism
  34. Chapter 34 — The God I Was Told About
  35. Chapter 35 — Another Idea of God
  36. Chapter 36 — Teaching Fear to Children
  37. Chapter 37 — What Children Are Taught Now
  38. Chapter 38 — When Religion Becomes Abuse
  39. Chapter 39 — Australia and the Child's Freedom of Thought
  40. Chapter 40 — Personal Sovereignty
  41. Chapter 41 — What the Creator Forgot to Tell Us
  42. Chapter 42 — When Mythology Comes Before Measurement
  43. Chapter 43 — Who Gets to Speak for Authority?
  44. Chapter 44 — When the Observer Becomes Part of the Event
  45. Chapter 45 — The Iatrogenic Loop
  46. Chapter 46 — When the Record Becomes More Powerful Than the Person
  47. Chapter 47 — Secular in Name
  48. Chapter 48 — Democracy, Representation and Who Holds Power
  49. Chapter 49 — Systems That Cannot Admit Error
  50. Chapter 50 — Authority Must Remain Answerable
  51. Chapter 51 — The System that Learns to Survive
  52. Chapter 52 — The Easy Correction
  53. Chapter 53 — When Reasonable People Disagree
  54. Chapter 54 — When the Same Thing Keeps Happening
  55. Chapter 55 — When Correction Becomes Costly
  56. Chapter 56 — What the Tests Found
All sections (13)

Browse the complete chapter.

The Branch ↑

There are memories from childhood that retain peculiar details.

Not necessarily the details somebody else would consider important.

A day of the week.

The position of a branch.

The colour of a hand.

A newspaper held up by a nurse.

One of those memories begins with some trees being felled.

I was watching from nearby with Johnny Lachlan.

We had been told to get out of the way and sit somewhere safe, among the branches of one of the trees that had already been brought down.

I found a branch perhaps two or three feet from the ground and used it as a seat.

The branch broke.

I fell backwards.

Instinctively I put my arm behind me to stop the fall.

I broke my elbow.

Hospital ↑

I finished up in the local hospital.

My father was at church.

One of the details that has stayed with me is that nobody was going to interrupt him to tell him that John was in trouble.

Religion had its order of priorities.

I was taken to hospital without him.

The local doctor was Charles Hosking.

His weekend drinking was well known around the town, as I remember it. I was later given to understand that he was still badly affected from the weekend when he treated me that Sunday.

I cannot independently reconstruct his condition now.

What I can reconstruct is what happened to me.

Waking Up ↑

I was given an anaesthetic.

Then there is a gap.

A long one.

My recollection is that it took almost two days before I properly woke.

When I did, my left arm was suspended from a pole.

There was a strap holding it up.

My hand was black.

There was black and purple bruising extending across my chest.

I was in considerable pain.

There were sandbags being used around the arm.

I did not understand what had happened while I was unconscious.

I only knew what I woke into.

Eventually the plaster was cut off.

The doctor wanted another attempt.

So I was anaesthetised again.

Again ↑

The second anaesthetic produced another long absence.

My recollection is that I remained asleep for about a day and a half.

Again there was difficulty waking me.

Again, when consciousness returned, my arm was suspended.

Again there was pain.

For a child, the medical details mattered much less than the pattern.

They put me to sleep.

I disappeared.

And I did not know when I would come back.

The doctor wanted to try again.

This time my mother refused.

Melbourne ↑

Arrangements were made to take me to Melbourne.

My father travelled with me.

I remember the doctor there as Peter Williams, although after so many years I would want to confirm the precise professional details from records if they still exist.

There was also a nurse whose name I remember as Nurse Wong.

She became the person I remember most clearly from that part of the experience.

I told her what had happened.

I told her that I was frightened of being given another anaesthetic.

That fear was no longer abstract.

Twice I had been put to sleep.

Twice I had apparently remained unconscious for vastly longer than anyone had expected.

I was terrified that if they put me under again I might not wake up.

Nurse Wong ↑

Nurse Wong listened.

She told me she would be there.

She reassured me that she would make sure I woke up properly.

I believed her.

That mattered enough for me to agree to the procedure.

There are moments in childhood when an adult makes a promise and the whole world temporarily rests on whether that promise can be trusted.

For me, this was one of them.

Before the anaesthetic she showed me the day's newspaper.

It was Thursday.

What Day Is It? ↑

When I woke, one of the first things I asked Nurse Wong was what day it was.

She said:

Thursday.

I panicked.

My immediate conclusion was that I had been unconscious for a week.

The previous two experiences had taught me that going to sleep under anaesthetic could mean disappearing for a very long time.

So when she said Thursday, my mind supplied the explanation.

It must be the next Thursday.

I had lost a week.

It took Nurse Wong a little while to realise what I was thinking.

Then she laughed.

Not at my fear.

At the misunderstanding.

She showed me the newspaper again.

The same Thursday.

I had been asleep for perhaps twenty minutes.

I remember that taking some time to register.

Twenty minutes.

Not two days.

Not a day and a half.

Not a week.

Twenty minutes.

The Meaning of Thursday ↑

It is strange what memory chooses to preserve.

I cannot reconstruct every medical conversation.

I cannot tell you exactly what drugs were used during each anaesthetic.

I cannot reproduce the clinical reasoning behind each attempt to set the elbow.

But I remember Thursday.

I remember the newspaper.

I remember asking what day it was.

I remember the terror of believing that an entire week had disappeared.

And I remember Nurse Wong understanding what had frightened me.

That is one of the differences between a medical record and a childhood memory.

A record might tell us the procedure.

It might tell us the anaesthetic.

It might document the fracture.

It might contain observations made by doctors and nurses.

But the event I carried forward was partly contained in one question:

What day is it?

My Mother's Refusal ↑

Looking back, another part of the story has become more significant.

My mother eventually said no.

After two attempts locally, after the prolonged periods in which I did not wake as expected, the local doctor wanted another attempt.

She refused.

That refusal changed what happened next.

I was sent to Melbourne.

I encountered different people.

And among them was Nurse Wong.

I do not want to reconstruct my mother's motives more precisely than I can remember them.

But the action itself is clear in my memory.

Enough.

Not again.

Adults and Authority ↑

As a child, hospitals were places in which adults made decisions.

Doctors knew things I did not.

Parents decided things.

Nurses carried out instructions.

A child could be moved, anaesthetised, plastered, suspended, transported and treated while understanding very little of the larger process.

That does not mean those adults were all the same.

This memory contains several very different forms of authority.

There was the authority of the local doctor.

There was my mother's refusal.

There was the medical team in Melbourne.

And there was Nurse Wong, whose authority with me came from something quite different.

She earned trust.

She told me she would be there.

Then, when I woke, she was there.

Burwood Road ↑

Afterwards I stayed for a time with my uncle Stan.

My memory places his business, J.C. Henry's Fine Furniture, on Burwood Road in Hawthorn.

That location connects this childhood hospital episode with other parts of the family history.

My brother Robert later went there in connection with an apprenticeship.

His story and mine intersect in ways that become much more difficult, including the shooting and what followed it.

Those events deserve their own space.

They should not be squeezed into the story of my elbow merely because memory places some of the same people and locations close together.

That is another discipline this book requires.

Association is not chronology.

A remembered connection may be important without belonging in the same chapter.

What the Child Knew ↑

The child in this story did not know about anaesthetic reactions.

He did not have a theory of medical error.

He was not making judgments about professional standards.

He knew something much simpler.

His arm was broken.

He had been put to sleep.

He had been very difficult to wake.

It had happened twice.

He was frightened of it happening again.

Then one adult listened to that fear and dealt with the child who actually had it.

That is what I remember.

Looking Back ↑

From the distance of old age, I could turn the episode into many different stories.

It could become a story about country medicine.

It could become a story about anaesthesia.

It could become another story about institutional power.

There may be records that would allow some of those questions to be examined properly.

But before any of those interpretations came the experience itself.

A boy fell backwards from a branch.

He broke his elbow.

He woke after an operation frightened and badly bruised.

He disappeared under anaesthetic again.

His mother eventually refused another attempt.

He was taken to Melbourne.

A nurse promised she would be there when he woke.

He opened his eyes.

He asked what day it was.

She said Thursday.

And for one terrible moment he thought he had lost an entire week.

Then she showed him the newspaper.

It was still Thursday.